Difference between revisions of "YTMND talk:Proposed Rules"
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
=Spamming= | =Spamming= | ||
| − | Define ''real effort''. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]] | + | Define ''real effort''. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]]<br> |
| + | I think it means "not sticking random images with random sounds." Classic style sites get a little bit of a pass in that way, because the image and sound often go together in an important way to make a joke. Taking images/sounds from the internet and uploading them to YTMND without reasonable modification would break that rule. [[User:BTape|BTape]] 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST) | ||
=Obscenity, Racism, Harassment, and shock value= | =Obscenity, Racism, Harassment, and shock value= | ||
| − | Define ''unnecessary amount''. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]] | + | Define ''unnecessary amount''. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]]<br> |
| + | This one is up to a moderator's judgment, unless a consensus can be reached on a boundary. [[User:BTape|BTape]] 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST) | ||
=General use of pornography= | =General use of pornography= | ||
| Line 13: | Line 15: | ||
=Voting Trends= | =Voting Trends= | ||
| − | Telling people how to vote is retarded, but whatever. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]] | + | Telling people how to vote is retarded, but whatever. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]]<br> |
| + | While some of the rules that fall under voting trends may be difficult to enforce, such as "revenge voting," I think there do need to be limits on the abusive voting habits that plague the site. [[User:BTape|BTape]] 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST) | ||
=Grouping up to push an agenda= | =Grouping up to push an agenda= | ||
=User Moderation Abuse= | =User Moderation Abuse= | ||
| − | Does ''incorrectly'' mean blatantly labeling an NSFW site of yours SFW, or does it also extend to being wrong about a borderline site? --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]] | + | Does ''incorrectly'' mean blatantly labeling an NSFW site of yours SFW, or does it also extend to being wrong about a borderline site? --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]]<br> |
| + | The punishments outlined currently are probably too harsh, but that can be changed. Yes, incorrectly marking a "borderline site" would fall under this rule. The planned moderation system may or may not have the same NSFW strictness it has now, though. [[User:BTape|BTape]] 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST) | ||
=Use of alternate accounts= | =Use of alternate accounts= | ||
| Line 24: | Line 28: | ||
| − | Oh God I'm fucked. --[[User:Kassius|Kassius]] 06:46, January 14, 2008 (CST) | + | Oh God I'm fucked. --[[User:Kassius|Kassius]] 06:46, January 14, 2008 (CST)<br> |
| − | + | All kinds of crazy, stupid shit here. This will kill a lot of good sites if you do this. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]]<br> | |
| − | All kinds of crazy, stupid shit here. This will kill a lot of good sites if you do this. --[[User:RySenkari|RySenkari]] | + | The punishments for improper citation might be lowered, but the emphasis is still put on crediting your sources. [[User:BTape|BTape]] 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST) |
=Just generally being a dumb idiot= | =Just generally being a dumb idiot= | ||
=Trying not to get caught= | =Trying not to get caught= | ||
=Miscellaneous= | =Miscellaneous= | ||
Revision as of 03:34, January 15, 2008
Discuss the rules or suggest your own.
Contents
- 1 Spamming
- 2 Obscenity, Racism, Harassment, and shock value
- 3 General use of pornography
- 4 Creating to or linking sites or comments glorifying generally illegal actions
- 5 Voting Trends
- 6 Grouping up to push an agenda
- 7 User Moderation Abuse
- 8 Use of alternate accounts
- 9 Meta Data
- 10 Just generally being a dumb idiot
- 11 Trying not to get caught
- 12 Miscellaneous
Spamming
Define real effort. --RySenkari
I think it means "not sticking random images with random sounds." Classic style sites get a little bit of a pass in that way, because the image and sound often go together in an important way to make a joke. Taking images/sounds from the internet and uploading them to YTMND without reasonable modification would break that rule. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
Obscenity, Racism, Harassment, and shock value
Define unnecessary amount. --RySenkari
This one is up to a moderator's judgment, unless a consensus can be reached on a boundary. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
General use of pornography
Creating to or linking sites or comments glorifying generally illegal actions
Voting Trends
Telling people how to vote is retarded, but whatever. --RySenkari
While some of the rules that fall under voting trends may be difficult to enforce, such as "revenge voting," I think there do need to be limits on the abusive voting habits that plague the site. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
Grouping up to push an agenda
User Moderation Abuse
Does incorrectly mean blatantly labeling an NSFW site of yours SFW, or does it also extend to being wrong about a borderline site? --RySenkari
The punishments outlined currently are probably too harsh, but that can be changed. Yes, incorrectly marking a "borderline site" would fall under this rule. The planned moderation system may or may not have the same NSFW strictness it has now, though. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
Use of alternate accounts
Meta Data
Oh God I'm fucked. --Kassius 06:46, January 14, 2008 (CST)
All kinds of crazy, stupid shit here. This will kill a lot of good sites if you do this. --RySenkari
The punishments for improper citation might be lowered, but the emphasis is still put on crediting your sources. BTape 03:34, January 15, 2008 (CST)
